4 Commercial Plumbing Estimating Challenges

Contractor fitting hydraulic components under a sink to complete a site installation

Commercial plumbing tenders can become difficult to price when drawings, specifications, quantities, supplier information and project requirements do not line up. These commercial plumbing tender challenges can lead to missed scope, incorrect labour allowances, and a tender price that does not reflect the work required. 

For experienced plumbing contractors, the difficulty is not simply measuring pipework. The challenge is making sure the quantities, installation requirements, and cost allowances are consistent with the current tender documentation.

1. Keeping Quantities Aligned with the Current Drawings

Commercial projects can involve several drawing revisions, addenda, and updated schedules. A takeoff based on an earlier revision can leave the tender with quantities that no longer represent the current design. 

Changes to a fixture schedule, pipe route, riser arrangement, or drainage layout can affect quantities already measured. Architectural and structural revisions can also affect the plumbing installation, even when the plumbing drawings have not been updated at the same time. 

Before using the quantities in the tender, check out the latest available drawings and schedules. Areas commonly requiring review include: 

  • Sanitary and water services 
  • Sewer and drainage 
  • Stormwater 
  • Fixtures and equipment 
  • Underground pipework 
  • Pits and associated drainage 

This review helps identify quantity changes before they are carried into the tender price.

2. Allowing Labour for the Actual Installation Conditions

Labour can be difficult to assess when a standard productivity allowance is used without considering how the plumbing will be installed. 

A commercial project may involve restricted ceiling spaces, congested plant rooms, high-rise vertical runs, underground excavation, staged construction, or difficult access. These conditions can significantly affect installation time. 

For example, a pipe run through an open commercial ceiling may have a very different installation requirement from a similar run through a congested ceiling containing electrical, mechanical and fire services. 

The labour allowance should therefore be reviewed against the project conditions shown in the documentation. A standard productivity rate can provide a starting point, but it should not replace a review of the actual installation environment.

3. Identifying Scope That Is Not Obvious from the Takeoff

Some common commercial plumbing estimating problems occur because requirements are spread across different parts of the tender documentation. 

A takeoff may capture the main pipework and fixtures while other requirements appear in the specifications, schedules or project conditions. Depending on the project, these can include: 

  • Pipe supports and brackets 
  • Valves and accessories 
  • Penetrations 
  • Testing and commissioning 
  • Connections to existing services 
  • Excavation and backfilling 
  • Builder’s work requirements 
  • Authority requirements 

These items do not necessarily represent large quantities individually, but several omissions can have a noticeable effect on the tender. 

The specifications and schedules should therefore be reviewed alongside the drawings rather than relying on the takeoff alone.

4. Checking Supplier Pricing Against the Tender Scope

Supplier quotations can provide the basis for material allowances, but the quotation still needs to be checked against the actual tender requirements. 

A supplier may quote the main pipe and fittings while excluding accessories, particular products, delivery or other items required by the project. Product substitutions can also create differences between the quoted materials and the specified requirements. 

The review should consider whether: 

  • The quoted quantities match the takeoff 
  • The products meet the project specifications 
  • Required accessories are included 
  • Supplier exclusions have been identified 
  • Freight and delivery have been allowed for where applicable 

Tender revisions create another potential issue. If the drawings or specifications change after supplier pricing has been obtained, the original quotation may no longer represent the current scope. 

Supplier pricing should therefore be reconciled against the latest tender information before it is incorporated into the price. 

Bringing the Four Areas Together 

These challenges are not isolated. A drawing of revision can change quantities, which then affects material requirements and labour. A supplier’s exclusion can also leave a scope gap that is not obvious from the takeoff. 

A useful tender review brings together the current drawings, specifications, takeoff quantities, supplier quotations, and labour allowances. This gives the contractor a clearer basis for checking whether the tender price reflects the work required. 

For commercial plumbing projects requiring detailed takeoffs, labour allowances, and project-specific tender pricing, contractors can also review commercial plumbing tender requirements against the current project documentation before submission. 

Contractor fitting hydraulic components under a sink to complete a site installation

Share:

More Posts

Send Us A Message